On being a consumer vs. being a creator

[annathepiper]

So yeah, the iPad has dropped, and it’s caused the obligatory storm of reaction all over the Net. Cory Doctorow in particular, I noted, had a very passionate post up on boingboing about why he’s not going to buy an iPad and why he thinks the rest of us shouldn’t either. Now, most of his arguments I’m not going to touch upon, but one thing I did want to mention was something I’ve seen brought up quite a bit elsewhere.

Which is to say, objections to the iPad on the grounds that it’s intended for people who want it to consume content, rather than create it.

And with all due respect, folks, I have to call bullshit on this on two grounds.

The first is that I’ve already heard people who’ve bought iPads geeking out about starting to write and do other creative tasks on them; rachelcaine, for example, I saw saying something about getting a wireless keyboard talking to hers. Related to this, speaking as someone who’s done a fair bit of writing on her iPhone, I can say right now without even having touched an actual iPad myself that I could write on one, too, if I wanted to. Sure, it’s being marketed with the overall idea of “look at how many shiny things you can watch or read on this, ain’t that neat?” But the point is, anybody who puts their mind to it can probably very quickly figure out how to make the device let them get some work done on it. Maybe not up to the same standards they could on other devices–and maybe those other devices let them get the job done better, which is why they prefer them. That’s fine, that’s not the part I take issue with.

Which leads me to my second point.

More than once I’ve seen this notion of “oh, the device is only meant to consume content, not create it”, presented in such a way that it somehow implies that consuming content is bad. This too is bullshit, and here’s why: there’s not a one of us who isn’t a consumer of content at some point. Every last one of us. We fling links to YouTube videos around. We all read blogs and online news. We laugh ourselves silly at pictures of funny cats. Even those of us who ostensibly fall into the “creative” camp gobble up our share of the content, and we all have our days when we’re consuming more content than we’re actually creating.

You know what, though? I think a lot of us creative types sometimes forget that the “consumers” are in fact the ones that we want buying our content. It’s easy to sneer at a device that’s only intended to let its user watch or read, but what about when the material being watched and read is something created by you?

“But Anna,” I hear you saying, “we’re only sneering at the people who let the content passively come to them and don’t let their imaginations be sparked by it!”

Again I say, bullshit. How can we know who’s going to be reading our books or listening to our songs at any given time? How can we predict how our work will engage them? What if a reader is a very quiet and private person who doesn’t feel the need to share with others how our work may have affected them, and just wants to keep the couple of hours of pleasure we may have given them to themselves, as a nice little experience they have to savor? Not everybody is an extroverted fan who will feel up to writing fanfic about our work, or composing filk, or jumping onto every forum or mailing list they’re on and gushing all about how awesome we are. Not everybody has the same creative spark we do.

And I really, seriously think that we creative types need to remember that. We need to remember that it’s okay if someone just wants to kick back for an hour or two and enjoy the content we’ve created without any expectations of how they should engage with it. We are, after all, hoping to entertain them. Let’s let them be entertained, okay?

And let’s let them do it on any devices they damn well please. If anybody out there is reading Faerie Blood or Defiance on an iPad, more power to you, and I thank you for your support!

Mirrored from angelakorrati.com.

Comments

[howlinhobbit.myopenid.com (from livejournal.com)]

Brilliant post.

Without an audience of consumers (however you define that term) creatives are pretty much left wanking all by their own little selves. I guess if that's what blows their hair back, that's OK, but I like sharing my music around a bit more than that.

[annathepiper]

Thank you very kindly!

And yeah. Not everybody is creative, and not everybody is creative in the same way.

[kisanthe.livejournal.com]

The hell? You mean... there are people who think it's bad to read a book, watch a movie, or listen to a song if you never intend to write, act, or compose yourself? That you must produce or you don't deserve techno-gadgets?

That crosses from bullshit into 'on what morning did I wake up to an insane world, 'cause I think I missed it' territory for me. I will defend to the death my right to own a PlayStation without any intention to write Aeris/Tifa tentacle hentai. I can listen to my iPod and not post badly-Photoshopped pics of Toby Keith in my bedroom with his head pastede on yay, dammit! My television is also not designed to help me create things. Clearly I should throw it out a window or something.

I say instead: you go, fellow consumers. Devour that delicious fantasy fiction like a cedar waxwing on berries and keep the publishing houses going.

[annathepiper]

Yeah, I've seen this attitude out there in a couple of places and it really annoys me, I have to say. Looking down your nose and proclaiming, "Create, not consume!" at people is a damn good way to get them to decide to not actually consume your stuff.

And given how shaky the publishing industry keeps claiming it is, that's exactly the wrong attitude to be encouraging! I hope all the iPad owners load those things up with all kinds of shiny, shiny ebooks and read the hell out of 'em.

[kisanthe.livejournal.com]

Seriously. Who do they think is buying their work, and where do they think they'd be if everyone were too busy creating in their limited free time to do any consuming at all?

It seems snotty to me, and shortsighted to boot. :P

[mmegaera.livejournal.com]

[whistles Twilight Zone theme]

Er, I want readers. Desperately. They're my Mecca.

I rather enjoy being one, too.

[annathepiper]

Seriously! I love, love, love my reading in all its myriad forms. :)